Family Horrors: 10 Movies Like Hereditary to Unsettle You

By Published On: May 29, 2024Last Updated: May 28, 20242996 words15 min read

Table Of Contents:

Movies Like Hereditary

Still haunted by the chilling scenes of “Hereditary“? If you’re yearning for more spine-tingling thrills, look no further. We’ve curated a collection of lesser-known horror gems guaranteed to leave you sleeping with the lights on.

Anything for Jackson (2020)

Prepare for a rollercoaster ride of terror in “Anything for Jackson.” Directed by Justin G. Dyck and written by Keith Cooper, this film delves deep into the psyche of grief-stricken grandparents who resort to dark, forbidden methods in their desperate quest to bring back their deceased grandson. As Audrey and Dr. Henry Walsh grapple with their overwhelming loss, they turn to sinister Satanic rituals, each step plunging them further into a world of darkness they never imagined.

Set against the backdrop of their secluded estate, the film immerses viewers in a chilling atmosphere filled with tension and dread. Every creaking floorboard and flickering shadow reminds us of the malevolent forces they’ve unleashed.

The standout performances by Sheila McCarthy as Audrey and Julian Richings as Dr. Henry Walsh add depth to the characters, making their descent into madness all the more compelling. McCarthy portrays Audrey’s fragile state with haunting authenticity, while Richings captures Dr. Walsh’s blend of determination and moral ambiguity.

As the demonic presence grows stronger and their grip on reality weakens, Audrey and Dr. Walsh must confront the horrifying consequences of their actions. “Anything for Jackson” masterfully blurs the lines between grief and obsession, delivering a chilling and unforgettable journey into the darkest depths of the human soul.

The Feast (2021)

Enter the unsettling world of “The Feast,” a cinematic masterpiece transcending traditional horror boundaries. Directed by Lee Haven Jones and penned by Roger Williams, this Welsh folk horror gem offers a unique and captivating experience that will linger in your mind long after the credits roll.

Set against the breathtaking backdrop of the Welsh countryside, “The Feast” transports viewers into a realm where ancient traditions collide with modern sensibilities. The film’s rich cinematography and immersive sound design create an atmosphere of palpable tension, drawing audiences into a world where every shadow conceals a dark secret.

At the heart of the narrative lies a tale of mystery and intrigue as a seemingly ordinary gathering takes a sinister turn. Annes Elwy delivers a mesmerizing performance as Cadi, a character whose enigmatic presence keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. As the events unfold, audiences are taken on a harrowing journey filled with unexpected twists and turns.

What sets “The Feast” apart is its ability to subvert expectations at every juncture. Just when you think you have unraveled its mysteries, the film pulls the rug out from under you, leaving you questioning everything you thought you knew. It is a testament to the filmmakers’ skill and vision that they are able to keep audiences guessing until the very end.

With its haunting imagery, captivating performances, and thought-provoking themes, “The Feast” is a true tour de force that showcases the very best of contemporary horror cinema. Whether you’re a seasoned horror aficionado or a casual viewer looking for a new thrill, this film is not to be missed. Prepare to be captivated, enthralled, and utterly terrified by “The Feast.”

Lovely Molly (2011)

Prepare to be engulfed in the chilling tale of “Lovely Molly,” a horror masterpiece that delves into the darkest recesses of the human psyche. Directed by the visionary filmmaker Eduardo Sánchez, this film offers a gripping blend of supernatural terror and psychological horror that will leave you questioning the very nature of reality.

At its core, “Lovely Molly” follows the harrowing journey of its titular character, portrayed with raw intensity by Gretchen Lodge. As Molly grapples with the recent loss of her father and her own personal demons, she becomes ensnared in a malevolent force that threatens to consume her from within. Lodge’s haunting performance brings Molly’s descent into madness to life, infusing the character with a vulnerability and depth that is both captivating and unnerving.

What sets “Lovely Molly” apart is its unflinching exploration of psychological trauma and the blurred lines between reality and nightmare. As Molly’s grip on reality unravels, the film plunges viewers into a nightmarish odyssey filled with visceral imagery and spine-chilling suspense. Eduardo Sánchez’s masterful direction keeps audiences on the edge of their seats as they are drawn deeper into Molly’s terrifying descent into madness.

But “Lovely Molly” is more than just a traditional horror film—it is a profound meditation on grief, guilt, and the human capacity for darkness. Through its richly layered narrative and complex characters, the film forces viewers to confront their deepest fears and insecurities. It is a visceral and deeply affecting experience that lingers long after the final credits have rolled.

With its haunting atmosphere, stellar performances, and thought-provoking themes, “Lovely Molly” stands as a testament to the power of horror cinema to both terrify and enlighten. Whether you’re a die-hard horror fan or simply seeking a film that will leave a lasting impression, “Lovely Molly” is an essential addition to your watchlist. Brace yourself for a journey into the heart of darkness—you won’t emerge unscathed.

A Dark Song (2016)

Embark on a harrowing journey into the depths of the unknown with “A Dark Song,” a mesmerizing tale of occult rituals and supernatural intrigue. Directed by Liam Gavin, this atmospheric thriller immerses viewers in a world where the boundaries between the physical and spiritual realms blur, and the quest for enlightenment comes at a chilling price.

At the heart of “A Dark Song” lies the enigmatic character of Sophia Howard, portrayed with haunting intensity by Catherine Walker. Desperate to communicate with her deceased son, Sophia enlists the help of the mysterious occultist Joseph Solomon, played with eerie charisma by Steve Oram. Together, they embark on a grueling and dangerous ritual that will test the limits of their sanity and resolve.

What sets “A Dark Song” apart is its meticulous attention to detail and unwavering commitment to authenticity. Director Liam Gavin draws upon centuries-old occult practices and esoteric symbolism to create a sense of palpable unease and dread. From the intricacies of ritualistic magic to the hauntingly beautiful cinematography, every aspect of the film is crafted with precision and care, drawing viewers deeper into its shadowy embrace.

As the ritual unfolds, “A Dark Song” becomes a mesmerizing exploration of faith, obsession, and the nature of existence itself. Sophia and Joseph’s journey is fraught with peril and uncertainty as they confront their deepest fears and darkest desires.

But “A Dark Song” is more than just a supernatural thriller—it is a profound and thought-provoking meditation on the human condition. Through its richly drawn characters and morally ambiguous narrative, the film challenges viewers to confront their beliefs and assumptions about life, death, and the existence of the divine.

With its spellbinding performances, evocative imagery, and profound thematic depth, “A Dark Song” is a testament to independent cinema’s power to captivate and provoke. Whether you’re a seasoned occult enthusiast or simply seeking a film that will leave you spellbound, “A Dark Song” is a journey into the unknown that is not to be missed. Prepare to confront the darkness within and unlock the universe’s secrets—it’s a ritual you won’t soon forget.

Caveat (2020)

Prepare yourself for a descent into darkness with “Caveat,” a chilling tale of isolation and psychological terror. Directed by Damian Mc Carthy, this Irish horror gem plunges viewers into a nightmarish world where reality blurs and the line between sanity and madness fades into obscurity.

At the heart of “Caveat” is the enigmatic character of Isaac, portrayed with haunting vulnerability by Johnny French. Struggling with amnesia, Isaac finds himself lured into a claustrophobic nightmare when he agrees to care for a troubled woman in a remote island home. Little does he know, he has unwittingly entered a labyrinth of psychological torment from which there may be no escape.

What sets “Caveat” apart is its masterful use of atmosphere and tension to evoke a sense of creeping dread. Every frame drips with palpable unease from the island house’s oppressive confines to its corridors’ eerie silence, drawing viewers deeper into its sinister embrace. As Isaac’s grip on reality unravels, the film becomes a gripping exploration of fear, paranoia, and the fragility of the human mind.

But “Caveat” is more than just a traditional horror film—it is a psychological tour de force that challenges viewers to confront their deepest fears and darkest impulses. As Isaac grapples with the demons of his past and the sinister forces that threaten to consume him, the film becomes a haunting meditation on guilt, trauma, and the nature of evil itself.

With its atmospheric visuals, spine-tingling sound design, and standout performances, “Caveat” is a testament to the power of indie horror to captivate and disturb. It delivers a nightmarish experience that is not easily forgotten. So steel yourself for a journey into the unknown, but be warned—once you enter the world of Caveat, there’s no turning back.

Amulet (2020)

Prepare to be ensnared in a web of darkness with “Amulet,” a haunting tale of dark secrets and supernatural forces. Written and directed by Romola Garai, this atmospheric horror film delves deep into the shadows of the human psyche, revealing horrors beyond imagination.

At the heart of “Amulet” lies the character of Tomaz, portrayed with haunting intensity by the talented Alec Secăreanu. A former soldier seeking refuge in London, Tomaz’s journey takes a sinister turn when he encounters a mother and daughter living in a dilapidated house. But as Tomaz becomes entangled in their lives, he soon discovers that the house holds dark secrets and malevolent forces that threaten to consume them all.

What sets “Amulet” apart is its ability to blend elements of psychological horror with supernatural terror, creating a gripping narrative that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. From the eerie silence of the house to the unsettling whispers that echo through its corridors, every moment is infused with a sense of creeping dread, drawing viewers deeper into its nightmarish world.

As Tomaz delves deeper into the house’s mysteries, he uncovers a more horrifying truth than he could have imagined. With its chilling narrative and standout performances, “Amulet” is a testament to the power of atmospheric horror to captivate and disturb. Whether you’re a fan of supernatural thrillers or simply seeking a film that will leave you questioning the nature of evil, “Amulet” delivers a haunting experience that will linger long after the credits roll. So brace yourself for a journey into the unknown, but be warned—once you enter the world of “Amulet,” there’s no turning back.

The Invitation (2015)

Prepare to be drawn into a world of escalating paranoia and chilling suspense with “The Invitation.” Directed by Karyn Kusama, this psychological thriller takes viewers on a tense and atmospheric journey through the shadows of the human mind.

At its core, “The Invitation” centers around a seemingly innocuous dinner party hosted by Will’s ex-wife Eden and her new husband. As Will and his girlfriend Kira arrive at the lavish Hollywood Hills home, they are greeted with warmth and hospitality. However, beneath the facade of civility lies an undercurrent of unease, as Will begins to suspect that there is more to the gathering than meets the eye.

What sets “The Invitation” apart is its masterful exploration of psychological tension and atmospheric dread. From the subtle glances exchanged between guests to the eerie silence that permeates the house, every moment is infused with a sense of impending doom, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats until the final, heart-stopping climax.

As the evening unfolds, Will’s suspicions are confirmed as he uncovers the true nature of the gathering—a twisted and sinister game orchestrated by Eden and her husband. With its gripping premise and taut screenplay, “The Invitation” is a testament to the power of psychological horror to disturb.

But beyond its surface thrills, “The Invitation” also offers a deeper exploration of grief, trauma, and the fragile nature of reality. As Will grapples with his own demons and struggles to separate fact from fiction, viewers are forced to confront their own fears and insecurities, blurring the line between fantasy and reality.

In the end, “The Invitation” is more than just a horror film—it’s a haunting meditation on the nature of paranoia and the darkness that lurks within us all. So dim the lights, brace yourself for a journey into the unknown, and prepare to be captivated by the chilling world of “The Invitation.”

Relic (2020)

Prepare to delve into the haunting depths of family ties and the horrors that lie beneath with “Relic.” This atmospheric horror film, directed by Natalie Erika James, offers a chilling exploration of dementia, aging, and the sinister forces that lurk within the family home.

Set against the backdrop of a secluded rural estate, “Relic” follows three generations of women—elderly Edna, her daughter Kay, and granddaughter Sam—as they grapple with the ravages of dementia and the unsettling mysteries that surround their ancestral home.

What sets “Relic” apart is its emphasis on psychological horror and slow-building tension. From the ominous creaks of the old house to the eerie manifestations of a malevolent presence, every scene is steeped in dread, leaving viewers on edge as they await the next terrifying revelation.

As Edna’s condition worsens and she begins to exhibit increasingly erratic behavior, Kay and Sam are forced to confront the unsettling truth about their family’s dark past. With each passing day, the boundaries between reality and nightmare blur, leaving the women questioning their own sanity and the true nature of the malevolent force that haunts their home.

But “Relic” is more than just a conventional horror film—it’s a poignant exploration of the complexities of family dynamics and the inexorable passage of time. As Kay and Sam struggle to come to terms with their mother’s deteriorating condition, they are forced to confront their own fears and insecurities, ultimately leading to a harrowing climax that will leave viewers breathless.

In the end, “Relic” is a haunting meditation on the legacy of trauma and the enduring power of familial bonds. With its gripping narrative, atmospheric cinematography, and standout performances, it’s a film that will linger in the mind long after the credits roll, serving as a chilling reminder of the horrors lurking within our lives’ shadows.

The Blackcoat’s Daughter (2015)

Step into the chilling world of “The Blackcoat’s Daughter,” where darkness lurks in the halls of a remote religious boarding school. Directed by Osgood Perkins, this horror masterpiece offers a slow-burn journey into the depths of despair and supernatural terror.

At the heart of the film are three young girls—Kat, Rose, and Joan—each grappling with their own inner demons amidst the austere confines of the boarding school. As the story unfolds, secrets are gradually unveiled, revealing a tangled web of lies, betrayal, and otherworldly forces.

Its masterful use of atmosphere and tension sets “The Blackcoat’s Daughter” apart. From the eerie silence of the empty corridors to the haunting whispers that seem to emanate from the shadows, every moment is suffused with an oppressive sense of dread, leaving viewers on edge as they await the next terrifying revelation.

But it’s not just the supernatural elements that make “The Blackcoat’s Daughter” so compelling—it’s also the psychological depth of its characters. As Kat, Rose, and Joan grapple with their own personal demons, their stories intertwine in unexpected ways, leading to a climax that is as shocking as it is satisfying.

At its core, “The Blackcoat’s Daughter” is a meditation on the nature of evil and the darkness that resides within us all. As the film reaches its spine-tingling conclusion, viewers are left questioning their own perceptions of reality and the true nature of the malevolent forces that lurk in the darkness.

With its haunting visuals, atmospheric score, and standout performances by its young cast, The Blackcoat’s Daughter will linger in the mind long after the credits roll, leaving viewers questioning what lies beyond the veil of darkness.

Starry Eyes (2014)

Prepare to descend into the cutthroat world of Hollywood with “Starry Eyes,” a chilling exploration of the price of success directed by Kevin Kölsch and Dennis Widmyer.

Sarah is a young actress with dreams of stardom. As she navigates the competitive landscape of the entertainment industry, she soon discovers that achieving fame comes at a cost she never could have imagined.

What sets “Starry Eyes” apart is its unflinching portrayal of the lengths to which people will go in pursuit of their ambitions. As Sarah becomes increasingly desperate to land her big break, she is drawn into a sinister world of manipulation, sacrifice, and unimaginable horror.

One of the film’s most compelling aspects is its exploration of body horror—a genre that delves into the visceral and grotesque aspects of the human body. As Sarah’s transformation unfolds, viewers are treated to a series of gruesome and unsettling scenes that serve as a stark reminder of the dangers of unchecked ambition.

But “Starry Eyes” is more than just a horror film—a biting critique of the entertainment industry and the toxic culture of fame. Through its portrayal of predatory producers, exploitative casting directors, and ruthless competition, the film shines a light on Hollywood’s dark underbelly, where success often comes at the expense of one’s humanity.

As Sarah’s journey reaches its shocking conclusion, viewers are left questioning the true cost of fame and the lengths they would go to achieve their own dreams. With its haunting imagery, powerful performances, and thought-provoking themes, “Starry Eyes” is a chilling reminder that the pursuit of success can sometimes lead to the darkest depths of the human soul.

There you have it— a handpicked selection of lesser-known horror films guaranteed to send shivers down your spine. Whether you’re drawn to supernatural terror or psychological dread, these films offer a captivating journey into the darkest corners of the human psyche. So dim the lights, grab your popcorn, and prepare for a night of chilling thrills unlike any other.